Knock, Knock, Knock, I open the door and it's the post man. Can you just sign here please he asks me as he hands me a parcel at the same time.
I sign his form and I look at the front of the package, it's the Pixel Bishop Radio Triggers that Uk Highland Photography are lending me, I said to my-self.
I made my way up to my studio, and just like a little child on Christmas Day I opened up my package. I opened the box and Wow.... A wee smile lit up on my face, I like that Pouch I said to my-self, it shows that the Manufacture does care about their product. I opened that case and I took out both the Transmitter and the Receiver. My first impression of the Pixel Bishop Radio Trigger was very, very, very good. To be honest with you I think that I was 100% impressed with them. Why? Well because...............
1) They did NOT feel cheap in your hands, 2) They have a Metal Hot Shoe with a Locking Pin, 3) They have all the cables included to shoot your Studio Lights / Speed Lights etc... 4) Again I really, really, really liked that pouch, 5) I had not even switched them on yet.
Yes, I was getting excited!! I mean come on, I have been for many, many months now triggering my SB900 with my trusty "Pocket Wizards Plus 11's". So to be giving this opportunity by UK Highland Photography to test drive the new Pixel Bishop Radio Triggers to see if they come even remotely close to the standards of the Pocket Wizard Plus 11's was just fantastic.
I inserted some fresh "High Power" batteries into both the Transmitter and the Receiver of the Bishops. I slide my SB600 onto the Hot Shoe of the receiver and I slide the Transmitter onto my Nikon D40. I switch on the Bishops, I set the Channels and the Groups, then press the shutter button and wow, I had just fired by SB600's for the very first time with a Radio Trigger. NB: Even though PW's are classed as being the best, the PW's don't give you the option to fire a speed light like the SB600 remotely with their Radio Triggers, perhaps the SB900 yes, but NOT with the SB600. So can you all see as to why I was amazed yet? The Bishops had just allowed me to fire my SB 600's with it's Radio Triggers, whilst my Pocket Wizard Plus 11's will never ever in their life time allow me to do such a thing.
The next thing that the Bishops allow me to do which the Pocket Wizards do not allow me to do. Is that the Bishops allow me to "Wake Up" my speed lights from their "Sleep" mode. Now this is a very good feature for the Bishops to have. With my PW's I have to switch the "Sleep" mode off on my sb900 prior to shooting. Other wise I will start having school boy tantrums every time I press the shutter and the speed light don't go off due to the fact that it is in it's "Sleep Mode".
The Bishops "Wake Up" feature works with your cameras auto focus, this means that when you "Half Press" your shutter button to lock on. It is then that the Bishops does use this "time period" to "Wake Up" your speed light. Now if you turn your auto focus off and shoot on "manual focus" then the "Wake Up" feature won't work as good / even at all due to the fact that the Photographer has giving the Bishops a no "Time Period" at all for the Bishops to wake up all those sleeping speed lights.
Ok but what about the "BIG BOY" stuff? How does the Bishops compare with the standards of the PW's? Well lets find out then and look at some of the results from my "Serious Tests" with the Bishops v PW's
----------------------------------------------------------------
Test 1: Pocket Wizards Are The Winners
---------------------------------------------------------------
Above: I cross the road ready to start my first test. |
Above: I shoot the Bishop... The door is open it's a clear Pass. |
Above: I shoot the Bishop... The door is closed it's a Fail. |
Above: I shoot the PW's... The door is closed it's a clear Pass |
----------------------------------------------------------------
Test 2: Bishop Triggers Are The Winners
---------------------------------------------------------------
What on God's green earth happened here then? The Bishop Triggers really did put my PW's to shame, on this next test of mine. Plus this test of mine was very fair to both the brands of Radio Triggers.
This is what I done, I carried out my test on the Middle Wood Way. And I used a hand help GPS to work out the exact / precise distance in Meters. My set up looked like this.........
1 x Light Stand + SB600 set on half power + Bishop Trigger
1 x Light Stand + SB900 set on half power + Pocket Wizard
Above: The image shows the exact location of my lighting set up. |
I slid the Bishop Trigger onto my Nikon D40 and I moved back 8 Meters and I fired my first shot. Great the Bishop Triggers work, so I put the PW's on to my Nikon D40 and took another shot,of course it worked.
Now I moved back to 36 Meters and put the Bishop Trigger back on my Nikon D40 took another shot, again the Bishop worked. So I put the PW's back on the D40 and shot again, of course the PW's worked.
Above: The Bishop is fired @ 8 Meters... it's a Pass |
Above: The PW's is fired @ 8 Meters... it's a Pass |
Now I moved back to 59 Meters, put the Bishop Trigger back on the Nikon D40 and again the flash from my SB600 Speed light went off. I put my PW's back on the D40 fired and to my horror, no flash appeared / came back from my SB900 Speed Light?
What? I said to my-self, so I tried again and then my SB900 fired it's flash. But still what is going on? The "FACT" is, is that my PW's failed to fire my SB900 from the 59 Meter mark. I put the Bishop Trigger back on the D40 again, and no problems what so ever it worked, over and over again it fired my SB600. However, on the other hand consistent tests from the 59 Meter mark with my PW's, seen my PW's develop a "Hit & Miss" attitude. Some times my SB900 went off other times it did not? hmmm........
Above: The Bishop is fired @ 36 Meters... it's a Pass |
Above: The PW's is fired @ 36 Meters... it's a Pass |
Then I had a thought, that thought was that my PW's unlike the Bishop Triggers did not have "fresh" batteries in them. So I took the batteries out of the 2 x Bishop Triggers and put them into my 2 xPW's. I walked back to 189 Meters and pressed the "TEST" button again on my PW's and bingo my SB900 went off at the distance of 189 Meters.
I pressed the "TEST" button on my PW's again.... but no flash came from my SB900........ I "WAVE" my arm above my head whilst pressing the "TEST" button at the same time on my PW's.... there I seen that, a flash came from my SB900.... I pressed the "TEST" button again..... again I seen "NO" flash from my SB900. It was clear to see that my PW's were doing a "Hit & Miss" thing.
I've had enough of this......... The Bishop Triggers have won this test.
Above: The Bishop is fired @ 59 Meters... it's a Pass |
Above: The PW's is fired @ 59 Meters... it's a Fail |
----------------------------------------------------------------
Test 3: I Say Bishops Win, Read Why!!
---------------------------------------------------------------
Above: An image shows the exact location of my lighting set up. |
Ok everyone please can you all look at the above screen shot of Torkington Park. Look at the “Ruler Box” contained with in that screen shot…. You see it yet? That line has been measured” in Meters”. So as you can see that line is only “217 Meters” long.
Now this is the very important bit………
1) Pixel Ltd claim that their Radio Trigger (NB: Bishops) fires up to 200 meters away.
2) LPA Design claim on the other hand that their Pocket Wizards Plus 11 fires up to 500 meters away.
So in my very last test we can all see that the actual shooting distance that I was shooting from was only 217 meters away from my speed lights.
In the previous test (NB: Test Two), we seen the Bishops activate my speed lights consistently with out any miss fires from a distance of 189 meters. So that is only 11 meters short of what the boys and girls at Pixel Ltd do claim that their Product can do..... Well done Pixel Ltd......
On the other hand my very more expensive Pocket Wizards Plus 11’s failed to activate my speed lights from the embarrassingly short distance of 59 Meters. That is a whopping 441 Meters short of what it is that LPA Design does claim that their product does do ? Not only that but in the same test (Test Two) the PW's were placed at 189 Meters away from my speed lights and they (PW’s) developed a “HIT N MISS” attitude.. This is still too a whopping distance of 311 Meters short of what LPA Design does claim that their product can do. But for real what is going on here LPA Design ?.... Don't you think that you have some explaining to do here ?
Moving on the final results of my final test revealed that ………
1) Both Radio Triggers developed a “HIT N MISS” attitude on this shoot.
2) This time the PW's activated my Speed Lights from the Longest Distance (193 Meters)
But……………………..
1) PW’s could NOT activate my speed lights from over the 217 Meters mark. Again what is going on LPA Design ? You claim that your product can trigger a flash from 500 Meters away!! (Your product can not even reach half way of what it is that you claim).
2) Bishops triggered my speed lights from (105 Meters) but that is still over half way of what Pixel Ltd do claim that their product does do.
Regards
Gareth Preston
www.strobist.tk
PS: I have my own theories as to why the PW's failed to do what LPA Design does claim that they can do. I am going to carry out some more vigorous tests on the PW's . With these tests that I plan to do with the PW's, then I'm pretty confident that the PW's may get closer to the 500 Meter mark that LPA Design do claim that they can do. The results of my tests / findings will be posted on a new / seperate blog posting. But again in this test / blog posting then again it's the Pixel Bishop Radio Trigger that's won this test, because again it does do exactly what it say's it does do on the box, that's why. End Of Story.
Now this is the very important bit………
1) Pixel Ltd claim that their Radio Trigger (NB: Bishops) fires up to 200 meters away.
2) LPA Design claim on the other hand that their Pocket Wizards Plus 11 fires up to 500 meters away.
So in my very last test we can all see that the actual shooting distance that I was shooting from was only 217 meters away from my speed lights.
In the previous test (NB: Test Two), we seen the Bishops activate my speed lights consistently with out any miss fires from a distance of 189 meters. So that is only 11 meters short of what the boys and girls at Pixel Ltd do claim that their Product can do..... Well done Pixel Ltd......
On the other hand my very more expensive Pocket Wizards Plus 11’s failed to activate my speed lights from the embarrassingly short distance of 59 Meters. That is a whopping 441 Meters short of what it is that LPA Design does claim that their product does do ? Not only that but in the same test (Test Two) the PW's were placed at 189 Meters away from my speed lights and they (PW’s) developed a “HIT N MISS” attitude.. This is still too a whopping distance of 311 Meters short of what LPA Design does claim that their product can do. But for real what is going on here LPA Design ?.... Don't you think that you have some explaining to do here ?
Moving on the final results of my final test revealed that ………
1) Both Radio Triggers developed a “HIT N MISS” attitude on this shoot.
2) This time the PW's activated my Speed Lights from the Longest Distance (193 Meters)
But……………………..
1) PW’s could NOT activate my speed lights from over the 217 Meters mark. Again what is going on LPA Design ? You claim that your product can trigger a flash from 500 Meters away!! (Your product can not even reach half way of what it is that you claim).
2) Bishops triggered my speed lights from (105 Meters) but that is still over half way of what Pixel Ltd do claim that their product does do.
So the winner is indeed…………………………. The Pixel Bishop Radio Trigger.... Why? Because it does do exactly what it say's it does do on the box, that's why. End Of Story.
Regards
Gareth Preston
www.strobist.tk
PS: I have my own theories as to why the PW's failed to do what LPA Design does claim that they can do. I am going to carry out some more vigorous tests on the PW's . With these tests that I plan to do with the PW's, then I'm pretty confident that the PW's may get closer to the 500 Meter mark that LPA Design do claim that they can do. The results of my tests / findings will be posted on a new / seperate blog posting. But again in this test / blog posting then again it's the Pixel Bishop Radio Trigger that's won this test, because again it does do exactly what it say's it does do on the box, that's why. End Of Story.
Above: Side by side Bishops & PW's under the night time sky. |